Interrogation
Machine: Laibach and NSK
by Alexei Monroe; Foreword by Slvoj Zizek
The MIT Press, Cambridge MA, 2005
400 pp., illus. 30b/w, 20 col. Paper,
$35
ISBN: 0-262-63315-9.
Reviewed by Michael R. (Mike) Mosher
Saginaw Valley State University
mosher@svsu.edu
Perhaps because I'm not an ethnic Slovene,
I don't appreciate the wit and subtlety
of the political imagery of Laibach and
NSK. Except for their opening of a mock
embassy, issuing passports and stamping
faux-official documents late in their
two-decade career, there isn't much sense
of fun to the body of artworks shown here.
Nevertheless, the philosopher Slvoj Zizek
finds it worthy of the attention Alexei
Monroe gives it in this thorough and detailed
book and provides its foreword.
The very name Laibach is provocative,
being the German name of the city of Ljubljana,
last used during the Nazi occupation.
For centuries there has been a strong
German element to Slovene culture, and
the Slovenes were the only Slavs that
were absorbed into the Third Reich rather
than considered conquered inferiors. Nationalism
came to a head with the post-Tito breakup
of Yugoslavia, the conflict between Serbia
and Croatia and the bloody "ethnic cleansing"
in Srebenica and Sarajevo. Throughout
this era NSK created artworks that employed
Germanic graphics, often juxtaposed with
similar Soviet socialist ones. The latter
included a print of a factory complex
that had been created by one member's
father much as the American collagist
Winston Smith uses images from 1950s magazine
advertisements that exude corporate confidence.
They also drew upon early twentieth century
avant-gardes, including John Heartfield's
anti-Nazi work (though Heartfield's swastika
assembled from fasces could be read positively
too).
To this reviewer, NSK and Laibach's imagery
is reminiscent of the use of Soviet and
Nazi imagery of strength and industry
by designers in London, New York, and
Los Angeles in the Punk and Post-punk
era, 1976 to 1984. This reviewer remembers
his own delight at the strangeness of
Maoist imagery the undergraduate found
at China Books stores in New York, Chicago,
and San Francisco in the 1970s, a burly
pink-cheeked female utility worker smiling
atop a telephone pole during a howling
storm (now that's sexy!). In Michigan,
Ron Asheton of the Stooges wore Wehrmacht
regalia onstage, and German electronic
band Kraftwerk parodied Third Reich (or
East German DDR) drones in their short
haircuts, tight collars, and neckties.
London Punk's use of the swastika, like
the surfers' Iron Cross in the 1960s,
tweaked the generation of fathers who
fought in World War Two. Susan Sontag's
1975 essay "Fascinating Fascism" charts
the militarist visual appeal that has
outlasted the Thousand-Year Reich by many
decades.
NSK used their imagery and cut-up and
repurposed lines from official Yugoslavian
pronouncements on culture in performances
throughout the 1980s. From NSK spun off
the band Laibachperhaps, like
San Francisco Punks, No Sisters, to provide
performances for which to make posters.
Not having heard Laibach's albums, this
reviewer finds their descriptionsBeatle
songs in martial choruses and choirs,
old German songs, industrial noise collages,
sped up tapesnot particularly
inviting. Perhaps like the Residents,
or the late Lester Bangs' favorite, Godz,
they are better read about than listened
to. In photographs Laibach sports a certain
bully boy macho that is ludicrous when
not dangerous (call them Sha Na Na-zis?);
Californians might be reminded of the
video of the art school Punk band, Crime,
dressed like stern prison guards while
playing for the amused inmates of Lompoc
state prison. Perhaps like Crime, Gwar,
Slipknot, or even Kiss, they are better
seen than heard.
While Laibach ("Better known than Ljubljana",
says author Monroe) have evidently embarked
on several successful European tours,
the non-European reader wonders exactly
who is their main audience. Do German
youth dig 'em? Slavic youth? It appears
that while stirring up controversy with
their imagery, they received much critical
acclaim and sporadic public support, perhaps
because they were homegrown Slovenes most
of all. This reviewer would have liked
to see this aspect of the NSK/Laibach
history compared to critical ethnic nationalistic
art produced under public art programs
in American cities. Monroe's book is detailed
and thorough, if perhaps as dry and humorless
as its subject. Interrogation Machine
will likely remain the central document
of these artists' historic moment in the
sun.