Tambogrande:
Mangos, Murder, Mining
by Ernesto Cabellos & Stephanie Boyd
First Run / Icarus Films, Brooklyn, NY,
2006/2007
DVD, 85 mins., col., b/w
Sales, $440; rental, $125
Distributors website: http://www.frif.com.
Reviewed by José-Carlos Mariátegui
Alta Tecnología Andina (Lima, Peru)
and London School of Economics (London,
UK)
jcm@ata.org.pe
The world of documentaries is always an
endeavor, specially when they are connected
with social circumstances in the intent
of summing up a situation in a particular
context. "Tambogrande: Mangos,
Murder, Mining" is a journalistic
documentary-analysis that tells the story
of the town of Tambogrande in the north
of Peru and the struggle of its people
against the exploitation of mineral resources
by foreign investors. I must say that
I have seen some documentaries similar
to this one in the sense that are quite
critical yet at the same time they develop
a journalistic story. In this case there
are very innovative elements, particularly
in the initial scenes, like a 2D collage
of photos that tried to create a historic
chronology of the city an its intense
relationship with agriculture rather than
mining. Also it was impressive some of
the digital images that tried to explain
how the city was going to be dismantled
due to the extraction by the Manhattan
mining company. However, those initial
visual innovative features of this documentary
are lost making the last 30 minutes a
bit repetitive in order to self-reinforce
the opinion of the people of the town.
There are ways of making this dialog much
richer, like by having also a good and
intelligent perspective of third parties
around the situation. Tambogrande
was an example of democratic participation
as it led the first local elections to
decide whether the mining company would
be able to exploit its land; and this
is more or less how the documentary ends.
However, we can see that unfortunately
there is just only one perspective of
the situation, and there is not an analysis
towards other deeper situations about
poverty and misery in those small towns.
The vision of Tambogrande, seen
as an agricultural town, becomes idealized,
particularly if we compare it with what
is happening today as many of their citizens
are dedicated to craft-mining, a poorly
technified and highly pollutant type of
mining.
Finally, in general, it must be said that
this documentary would have been more
powerful if there was a more convincing
argument. The somewhat experimental initial
sequences mixed with the story of Tambogrande,
becomes more a journalist pursuit than
a critical documentary. It is however
a pity that these types of documentaries,
which are few and good exemplars of independent
productions, are not included under CC
license to be included online and therefore
they have to struggle against oblivion.